Skip to main contentSkip to footer

Commercial and insurance value estimates

How much is my boat worth? It seems like a question with a single answer, but it actually depends on who asks it and why. With a used boat appraisal, I can determine the value you need to sell, insure, divide an inheritance, or terminate a lease, and I'll explain how to get there. I work for shipowners, heirs, lawyers, insurance companies, leasing companies, and finance companies.

Marco Casari Estimates-nautical-value-commercial-and-insurance

Commercial, insurable, and new value: which one do you need?

Market value is the current market value, between buyers and sellers. It's used to sell, divide assets, or obtain a lease.

The insurable value is the amount for which you insure it. This is what matters for hull insurance.

The new, or replacement, value is how much an equivalent boat would cost today. Some policies use it as a fixed sum; others follow the current value, with age deductions in the event of damage.

Before estimating, I'll help you understand which one you need. In the report, I'll list the value I've sought, the date, and the criteria, so anyone can verify the figure. You can find the other tasks in Services.

Why an ad is not an appraisal of a used boat

The price listed on a listing is the seller's hope, not the price the boat is selling for. Online price lists and quotes provide a rough estimate: they're useful for orientation, not for decision-making.

The price paid years ago says little about today, and not every improvement is worth its price. For rare or highly customized models, online searches are even less helpful: there are few similar boats for sale.

If you are buying, the estimate goes along with the pre-purchase appraisalFirst the condition of the boat, then how much it's worth.

Estimating the value of your boat: what it really weighs

Two boats of the same year and model can be worth vastly different amounts. More important than age is the proven maintenance: service records, work invoices, and operating hours consistent with use.

Brand, current demand, area, and season also play a role: a lesser-known brand is more difficult to evaluate because there are few comparisons.

Then there are the flaws that aren't visible: for the buyer, these are work to be paid for, hence a discount. For this reason, I check the condition of the hull, engines, and systems with a hygrometer, thickness gauge, and thermal imaging camera. A water test isn't always necessary: we decide on a case-by-case basis.

The documents to be prepared are those of the pre-purchase survey: vessel papers, engine logbooks, RINA inspections and work history.

Insurance appraisal for hull policy

Hull insurance covers damage to the boat itself, not damage you cause to others.

Under the Civil Code, damages are calculated based on the value of the vessel at the time of the accident, not on a higher value. However, the value can be established upon signing the contract with an estimate accepted in writing by the parties. A simple declaration of value in the policy is not equivalent to an estimate (Article 1908 of the Civil Code). If the insured sum covers only a portion of the value, the insurer pays proportionately, unless otherwise agreed (Article 1907 of the Civil Code).

Check what your policy covers. For boats that are a few years old or made of wood, some companies require a condition assessment by an expert. If the damage is already present, you'll need a damage and accident assessment.

Inheritance, separations, leasing: an appraisal that holds up

For inheritance tax purposes, the value of vessels not owned by a company is calculated based on the average new prices of the same type. The time elapsed since purchase and the vessel's condition are taken into account (Article 15, paragraph 2, Legislative Decree 346/1990). The condition of the vessel is not listed on a price list: it must be verified on board. A notary or accountant will assist you with the declaration.

Between heirs, separating spouses, or those with a lease, a figure everyone can control is needed. I'll deliver the report within 24-48 hours, in PDF or another format, even in another language. If it needs to have legal validity, the I certify before a notary. I sign this as a nautical surveyor registered under no. 667 of the Register of Surveyors and Experts of the Brescia Chamber of Commerce, a profession I have practiced for over 20 years.

Vintage and collectible boats

With a vintage boat The price list almost never helps. Here I also estimate the insurance and collector's value: I analyze the documents, inspect the boat, evaluate its state of preservation, how original it remains, and the work done over time. Then I look at the model's history and the prices of similar units on the international classic boat market.

If you want to get an idea of how I work, below are some boats I've appraised, from wooden Rivas to newer yachts.

Solaris Power 48 Open moored in port, with the cockpit covered by grey tarpaulins
Solaris Power 48 Open Insurance Appraisal Hull Policy
sunseeker 55 insurance appraisal survey
Sunseeker 55 Insurance Estimation Survey
Riva Aquariva 33 Cento with dark hull in covered storage
Riva Aquariva Cento Insurance Survey Policy Bodies
White Riva St Tropez on a dock in a storage shed
Riva St Tropez Insurance Estimation Survey
Blue Colombo Aliante 32 on a trolley under a canopy, with the stern drives visible
Columbus Glider 32 Insurance Estimation Survey For Bodies Policy
Chrome Aquarama Super lettering on the mahogany of a Riva speedboat
Riva Aquarama Super appraisal for inheritance

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the insured value be different from the commercial value?

Yes: one tells you how much the boat is worth on the market, the other how much to insure it for. In the event of damage, the policy terms and any written estimate agreed to by the company are important: reread them before renewing.

How long is an estimate valid for?

The value refers to the day of the appraisal. The market and the boat change thereafter. It's a good idea to update it when the company requests it or after major work or new equipment.

Can I know how much the boat is worth from photos and documents?

Yes, with the Preliminary Technical Consultation: Using photos, videos, and documents, I can give you a fair estimate of the value, although it's less accurate than an onboard appraisal. Consultations start at €350 remotely and €500 in person.

Do you need an estimate?

Tell me what kind of boat it is, where it's located, and what you need the value for: sale, insurance, inheritance, separation, or leasing. From there, I'll tell you what appraisal to make.

If you want some guidance first, start from Preliminary Technical Consultation remotely, starting from €350.

Do you want a Preliminary Technical Consultation?

Discover the service from €350 remotely

Affiliations and roles

logo-brescia-chamber-of-trade

Nautical surveyor registered in Roll No. 667

Chamber of Commerce of Brescia

Italian Powerboating Federation (FIM) logo

Race Official – Technical Consultant

Italian Powerboating Federation (FIM)

International Institute of Marine Surveying (IIMS) logo

IIMS Affiliate Member

International Institute of Marine Surveying